Quick answer: DADT (don’t ask, don’t tell) in ENM is an agreement where partners are free to see other people but agree not to ask about, or share, the details. Both know the relationship is non-monogamous, which is what separates it from cheating. It can suit people who want privacy or less jealousy, but it works best with a few things always shared, like sexual health and schedules.
Don’t ask, don’t tell (DADT) is one of the most talked-about, and most debated, agreements in Ethical Non-Monogamy (ENM). Some partners want to hear everything about each other’s dates; others would rather know the relationship is open and leave it there. DADT is the name for the second approach.
Within the ENM community opinions are strong on both sides. This guide explains what a DADT relationship is, where the phrase comes from, the different versions couples use, the honest pros and cons, how to set one up, warning signs that it’s not working, and what to do if you want to change it.
What is DADT in ENM?
The term “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” (DADT) comes from a US military policy introduced in 1994. It barred gay, lesbian and bisexual people from serving openly: they could serve only if they kept their orientation secret, and commanders weren’t supposed to ask.
The policy was repealed in full on 20 September 2011 (Human Rights Campaign), but the phrase lives on in other contexts, including Ethical Non-Monogamy.
In the context of ENM, DADT refers to a mutual agreement between partners where they choose not to ask about each other’s romantic or sexual relationships with other people, and do not volunteer those details either.
Simply put, it is an agreement to not discuss or enquire about the specifics of each other’s connections with others.

For example, in a DADT relationship, one partner may be dating other people or having casual sex outside of the primary relationship but won’t share the details (names, experiences, etc.) with their primary partner.
Likewise, the primary partner does not ask about or expect to know details about these encounters.
The goal is to allow both individuals to explore their other relationships without the pressure or discomfort of sharing those specifics.
Why Do Some People Choose DADT in ENM?
There are several reasons why couples in ENM might adopt a DADT approach:
Avoiding Jealousy and Emotional Overload
For some, knowing the details of their partner’s other relationships can lead to feelings of jealousy, insecurity, or emotional overwhelm.
A DADT policy can help reduce these feelings by limiting the information that could potentially cause distress.
Maintaining Boundaries and Privacy
Some partners prefer to keep certain aspects of their relationships private.
A DADT agreement allows for a boundary where each person maintains their privacy and does not feel obligated to share personal details they deem unnecessary or uncomfortable.
Preventing Comparisons
In relationships where one partner is dating multiple people, it’s common to avoid comparing relationships.
DADT can help by keeping the focus on the primary partnership without needing to measure it against secondary connections.
Fostering Trust and Respect
In certain ENM dynamics, DADT can be seen as an act of respect and trust.
The idea is that each person trusts the other to handle their relationships with integrity without needing to micromanage every interaction or feeling the need to disclose every detail.

The Pros and Cons of DADT in ENM
While DADT works for some couples, it’s important to examine both the benefits and potential drawbacks of this arrangement.
Pros:
Reduced Emotional Stress: Some partners find that by avoiding constant discussions of their other relationships, they can focus on the core of their primary relationship and avoid unnecessary emotional conflict.
Preservation of Privacy: In an age where personal lives can often feel overexposed, DADT offers a way to preserve privacy without sacrificing connection and intimacy.
Encourages Freedom: DADT allows partners the freedom to explore their desires and connections with others without feeling they need to justify or explain every aspect of those relationships.
Cons:
Potential for Miscommunication: DADT can sometimes create a lack of communication or transparency in the relationship. Without discussing feelings or concerns, partners may assume everything is fine when issues (like jealousy or emotional discomfort) could be festering beneath the surface.
Resentment or Deception: If one partner feels they are being kept in the dark or lied to, they may experience feelings of resentment or distrust. This can create a divide between partners if not handled carefully.
Not for Everyone: Some people in ENM relationships prefer to know details about their partner’s other relationships, believing that openness fosters a deeper connection and strengthens trust. For these individuals, DADT may feel like a wall between them and their partner.

Common Types of DADT Agreements
DADT isn’t one fixed rule. Couples usually pick a version that fits them:
- Full DADT: no details at all about other partners or dates.
- Soft DADT (or “need to know”): no stories or names, but you share anything that affects the other person, such as overnight plans, schedule changes or sexual health.
- DADT with honesty on request: you don’t volunteer details, but either partner can ask a direct question and get a truthful answer.
- Time-limited DADT: used while one partner settles into non-monogamy, then reviewed.
What DADT Should Still Include
Even the strictest DADT agreement works best with a few things that are always shared:
- Sexual health: testing, barrier use and any STI exposure that could affect your partner. Our Safer-Sex Conversations Worksheet helps you agree this in advance.
- Time and logistics: when you’ll be out or away, so plans aren’t a surprise.
- Big changes: falling in love, a relationship becoming serious, or anything that could change your shared life.
- Regular check-ins about the agreement itself: not the details, but how DADT is feeling for both of you. The Weekly Check-In Cards are designed for this.
Writing it down helps. The ENM Relationship Agreement Template has space for disclosure rules like these. For the health side in more depth, see our guide on how to manage sexual health in non-monogamy.
How to set up a DADT agreement
If you’re both drawn to DADT, a little planning makes it far more likely to feel safe rather than lonely.
- Check your reasons, separately. Ask yourself: “Do I want not to know, or am I afraid to know?” Wanting privacy is different from hoping that not hearing about it will make difficult feelings go away.
- Choose your version. Full DADT, soft DADT, honesty on request or time-limited (see above). Be specific: does “don’t tell” cover names? Dating apps? Overnights?
- List what is always shared. At minimum: sexual health, time away and big emotional changes.
- Agree on the practical edges. Not bringing dates home, not dating mutual friends or co-workers, and what happens if you bump into each other’s dates in public.
- Decide how other partners will know about it. The people you date deserve to know you’re in a DADT arrangement, so they understand why they may never meet your partner. Our guide to creating a polyamorous dating profile covers being upfront about your setup.
- Set a review date. Try one or three months, then talk about how it feels.
Some words that help:
- “I’m happy for us to be open, but I don’t want to hear about dates. Could we agree you’ll still tell me about anything health-related or anything that affects our plans?”
- “If I ever ask you a direct question, would you rather answer honestly or remind me of our agreement?”
- “Can we check in next month about how DADT is feeling, not the details, just us?”
Warning signs DADT isn’t working
DADT can drift from “private” to “avoidant” without anyone noticing. Signs it may need a rethink:
- One of you is quietly anxious, checking phones or imagining the worst more and more.
- “Don’t tell” has started to cover things that affect you, like money, time or health.
- You agreed to DADT mainly so a partner would agree to opening up, and you’d actually prefer more openness (or no opening at all).
- Check-ins have stopped, or feel tense and short.
- A partner’s other relationship has clearly become serious, and that’s never been discussed.
- Other partners feel hidden or are being asked to keep secrets that make them uncomfortable.
If several of these ring true, it doesn’t mean you’ve failed. It means the agreement needs updating, which is normal.
Is DADT Ethical in ENM?
If both partners freely agree to DADT and are honest about their boundaries, it can be an ethical approach. DADT does not mean that one partner is lying or cheating; it means they have agreed not to discuss certain parts of their lives.
Research gives some useful context. A 2019 University of Rochester study of 1,658 people, published in the Journal of Sex Research, found that people in consensually non-monogamous relationships reported relationship satisfaction and well-being similar to monogamous people, while “partially open” and one-sided arrangements, with less consent, comfort and communication, did worse (University of Rochester). The study didn’t look at DADT specifically, but lead researcher Ronald Rogge warned that “secrecy surrounding sexual activity with others can all too easily become toxic.” The takeaway: DADT is on firmer ground when it’s chosen by both people and comfortable for both, not tolerated by one.
There’s a third party to think about too. The people your partner dates are affected by DADT, and they should know about it. Being kept invisible can feel very different from choosing privacy, so honesty with everyone, not just your partner, is part of keeping DADT ethical. Our guide to veto power in ENM looks at a related question: how much say partners should have over each other’s other relationships.
As long as consent is mutual and both parties are comfortable with the arrangement, DADT can work in an ethical non-monogamous framework.
However, it’s essential for partners to regularly check in with each other to ensure that no one feels neglected or unfulfilled.

DADT vs. Other ENM Models
DADT sits at one end of a spectrum of how much partners share. Here’s how it compares with other common approaches:
| Approach | How much is shared | Do partners meet metamours? |
|---|---|---|
| DADT | That the relationship is open, plus agreed essentials | Usually not |
| Parallel polyamory | Varies; often full knowledge, but separate lives | Rarely or briefly |
| Full transparency | Most or all details, often by request | Varies |
| Kitchen table polyamory | Open sharing | Yes, often as friends |
Note that DADT is about information, while parallel and kitchen table describe how much contact people have; you can be parallel without being DADT. Our guides to types of polyamory and types of open relationships explain these styles in more depth.
Some people prefer a more open and communicative approach, where details about other relationships are shared and discussed openly.
Others might practice polyamory or relationship anarchy, where honesty, vulnerability, and communication are prioritized, and every relationship is treated as equally important.
It’s important to remember that the key to any successful ENM arrangement is clear communication about boundaries, expectations, and consent.
If both partners are happy with the DADT model, then it can work well. However, it should never be imposed on one partner without their consent.

Frequently asked questions
Is a DADT agreement suitable for all non-monogamous relationships?
No, a DADT agreement is not suitable for everyone. It works best for couples who are confident in their communication and trust, and who prefer to keep certain aspects of their external relationships private. It’s essential for both partners to agree on and feel comfortable with this arrangement.
How does a DADT agreement impact emotional intimacy in a relationship?
A DADT agreement can impact emotional intimacy in different ways. For some, maintaining privacy can help protect the primary relationship from jealousy and conflict, thereby preserving emotional closeness. For others, the lack of transparency might create a sense of emotional distance. Regular check-ins and honest communication about the agreement itself can help mitigate negative impacts on intimacy.
Is DADT the same as cheating?
No. Cheating breaks an agreement and relies on deception. In DADT, both partners know and agree that the relationship is non-monogamous; they’ve simply chosen not to share details. If one partner doesn’t actually know the relationship is open, that’s not DADT. For more, see cheating in an open relationship.
Why is DADT controversial in the poly community?
Critics argue it can hide problems, make metamours invisible and leave one partner quietly unhappy. Supporters say it gives privacy and reduces jealousy for people who don’t want details. Both can be true. It depends on whether the agreement is chosen freely and checked regularly.
What should we do if a DADT agreement is no longer working for us?
If a DADT agreement is no longer serving your relationship, it’s important to discuss your feelings openly and honestly. You might consider revising the agreement, exploring other forms of non-monogamy, or seeking guidance from a relationship counselor experienced in Ethical Non-Monogamy. The key is to ensure both partners feel heard, respected, and satisfied with the arrangement. Our How to Bring Up ENM: Conversation Scripts printable has kind, honest wording for hard relationship conversations like this one.
Can DADT work in polyamory, or only in open relationships?
It’s most common in sexually open relationships and swinging-style arrangements, where outside connections are often casual. It’s harder in polyamory, where other relationships can become long-term and loving, and it becomes difficult not to know about someone who’s an important part of your partner’s life. Some polyamorous people use a soft, “need to know” version instead.
In closing
Don’t ask, don’t tell can be a helpful tool for some people seeking to explore non-monogamy without hearing the details of each other’s other relationships. For others it feels distant or too close to secrecy. Neither reaction is wrong.
What makes DADT ethical isn’t how much you share, but whether you both freely chose it, everyone involved knows about it, essentials like sexual health are always shared, and you keep checking in on how it feels. Agreements can change, and it’s fine to start with DADT and move towards openness, or the other way round. This article is general information, not professional advice.
Sources
Enjoyed this article?
Get new articles in your inbox, plus reading paths and the occasional new tool. Unsubscribe in one click.
You’ll receive a confirmation email first. Privacy policy



