bigamy vs polygamy

Bigamy vs Polygamy: What is the Difference?

Quick answer: Bigamy is the crime of marrying someone while you are still legally married to another person; every US state bans it, as do the UK and Canada. Polygamy is the broader practice of having more than one spouse at the same time, and some countries recognize it, mostly in parts of Africa, the Middle East and Asia. Put simply, “bigamy” is usually the legal name for a second marriage the law doesn’t allow, while “polygamy” describes the marriage pattern itself.

People often search “bigamy vs polygamy” because the two words sound interchangeable. They overlap, but they are used very differently. Bigamy is marrying one person while you are still legally married to another, and it is a crime in most Western countries. Polygamy is the wider practice of having more than one spouse at the same time, which some cultures, religions and legal systems accept.

Below we unpack the definitions and where the words come from, what the law says in the US, UK and Canada, why the US bans plural marriage, whether you can commit bigamy by accident, and where consensual non-monogamy and polyamory fit in. The legality of bigamy and polygamy varies a lot from place to place, so treat this as a plain-English overview.

Please note: this article is general information, not legal advice. Anna is not a lawyer. If you have a question about your own marriage, divorce or immigration status, please talk to a qualified lawyer where you live.

Definitions

When discussing marital relationships, it’s crucial to understand the distinctions between different forms of multiple spouse arrangements. Know that bigamy and polygamy are two different practices with their own definitions and legal considerations.

Bigamy

Bigamy occurs when you are legally married to one spouse and subsequently enter into a marriage with another person without legally dissolving the first marriage. In many jurisdictions, bigamy is a criminal offense because you are legally bound to only one spouse at a time.

Polygamy

Polygamy is a broader term that refers to the practice of having multiple partners or spouses simultaneously. This can take various forms:

  • Polygyny: When a man is married to more than one wife.
  • Polyandry: When a woman has multiple husbands.
  • Group marriage: Where several individuals enter into a marital agreement together.

The practice of polygamy is accepted in some cultures and religious communities; however, it’s important to note that in many places, polygamous marriages are not legally recognized.

Where the words come from

Both words share the Greek root gamos, “marriage”. Polygamy adds poly-, “many”, so it simply means “many marriages”. Bigamy adds the Latin bi- (from bis, “twice”), so it literally means “married twice”; it reached English through Late Latin bigamia and French bigamie (Wiktionary). That is why the two overlap: a bigamist technically has a polygamous marriage. The difference is in how the words are used. “Polygamy” describes a family structure, which may be lawful where it is practiced. “Bigamy” is mostly a legal term for a second marriage that a country’s law forbids.

A simple example

Imagine Sam marries Alex, they separate, but the divorce is never finalized. A few years later Sam marries Jordan. In the US, the UK or Canada, that second marriage is bigamous: it is not legally valid, and Sam could face criminal charges. Now imagine a Muslim man in the Philippines who marries a second wife under the country’s Code of Muslim Personal Laws. That code allows more than one wife only where the husband can give them “equal companionship and just treatment”, and its Article 180 says the bigamy provisions of the Revised Penal Code do not apply to marriages made under it. Same country, two marriages each, but only one is the crime of bigamy.

bigamy vs polygamy

Legal Perspectives

In the United States, the UK and Canada, a person can only be legally married to one spouse at a time. Here is what that means in practice.

Legal Consequences of Bigamy

Bigamy, in the eyes of the law, is a criminal offense that occurs when you marry someone while you are still legally married to another person. If you are found guilty of bigamy, you can face a range of penalties including fines, annulment of the second marriage, or even jail time. The actual consequences can vary depending on the jurisdiction. In many cases, bigamy is regarded as a felony or a misdemeanor. The issuance of multiple marriage licenses to you without the prior ones being legally ended will lead to the nullification of the later legal marriages and possible legal repercussions.

Recognition of Polygamy in Law

On the other hand, polygamy, having more than one spouse, has no legal standing in the United States: no state will issue a marriage license to someone who is already married, and every state bans bigamy. Penalties differ. In 2020 Utah passed S.B. 102, which made bigamy between consenting adults an infraction, the lowest level of offence and punishable by a fine, rather than a felony, while keeping felony penalties when bigamy is induced by fraud, threats or coercion, or goes along with crimes such as abuse or trafficking. That is a lower penalty, not legal recognition: Utah still treats only one marriage as valid. Polygamy can also matter for immigration, since it can lead to deportation or delay citizenship.

Outside the US, the UK makes bigamy a crime under section 57 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861, with exceptions for a former spouse who has been continually absent for seven years, a divorce or a court ruling that the first marriage was void. Canada has two separate offences: bigamy under section 290 of the Criminal Code, and polygamy, or “any kind of conjugal union with more than one person at the same time”, under section 293, punishable by up to five years in prison. For a country-by-country look, see our guide to whether polygamy is legal.

Why the US bans plural marriage

The US ban has its roots in the 19th-century conflict over plural marriage in the Latter-day Saint community in Utah Territory. In 1862 Congress passed the Morrill Anti-Bigamy Act, which outlawed bigamy in the federal territories. It was hard to enforce at first, but in 1879 the Supreme Court upheld a prosecution under it in Reynolds v. United States (more on that case below). When Utah became a state, its constitution included the line that “polygamous or plural marriages are forever prohibited”, and it is still in Article III of the Utah Constitution today. Since then, US family law has been built around marriage between two people: tax rules, inheritance, parental rights and spousal benefits all assume one spouse at a time.

Can you commit bigamy by accident?

Sometimes people end up in a second marriage without meaning to break the law, for example when they believe a divorce was finalized and it wasn’t. US states handle this through defenses written into their bigamy laws. Two examples:

  • Illinois defines bigamy as when a married person “knowingly marries another”. Its statute (720 ILCS 5/11-45) gives a defense if the earlier marriage was dissolved or declared invalid, if the accused reasonably believed the earlier spouse was dead, if that spouse had been continually absent for five years and wasn’t known to be alive, or if the accused reasonably believed they were legally free to marry. Bigamy there is a Class 4 felony, and knowingly marrying a bigamist is a separate misdemeanor.
  • Colorado’s bigamy statute has similar defenses (a reasonable belief that the former spouse was dead, five years of continual absence, or a reasonable belief that you were free to remarry). It also covers civil unions, and since March 2022 bigamy there is a class 2 misdemeanor rather than a felony.

Even where a defense applies, the second marriage is usually still not legally valid. In practice the fix is to end it properly, often through an annulment, and then remarry if both people want to. If this is your situation, a family lawyer can tell you how the rules work where you live.

Cultural and Religious Views

Polygamy in Different Cultures

Polygamy has a diverse cultural history across the globe and is entangled with the social fabric of many societies. For instance, in parts of Africa and Asia, having multiple spouses is a centuries-old cultural practice, often tied to social status and familial legacy. In modern times, however, the practice is generally in decline and is illegal in most countries, though it persists in some cultural pockets.

Some Native American tribes historically practiced polygamy as well, linking it to kinship systems and community structure. Whether through arranged marriages or alliances, the practice served crucial cultural functions.

Religious Contexts and Polygamy

Within religious contexts, polygamy can take on varied meanings and implementations. In Islam, for example, a man may marry up to four wives on condition that he treats them fairly and equally, and many Muslims see that condition as hard to meet. How this works in practice depends on national law, which ranges from outright bans to permission with conditions. The Philippines’ Code of Muslim Personal Laws, mentioned above, allows a second wife only “in exceptional cases” and only where the husband can give “equal companionship and just treatment”.

The history of polygamy in Christianity is complex, with most mainstream denominations now opposing it. However, groups such as the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS) continue the practice, seeing it as part of their religious heritage. These splinter sects operate on the fringes of the wider LDS movement, which ended new plural marriages with President Wilford Woodruff’s 1890 Manifesto, advising members to “refrain from contracting any marriage forbidden by the law of the land”. If you want to understand what leaving these communities involves, our guide to escaping polygamy covers it.

bigamy vs polygamy

Social and Ethical Considerations

Consensual vs. Non-consensual Relationships

Consent is the cornerstone of consensual non-monogamy. In a consensual polyamorous relationship, all parties involved agree to the arrangement. This contrasts with non-consensual relationships where deceit can play a role, as is often associated with bigamy. Bigamy involves a spouse marrying another without their mate’s knowledge, which infringes on the trust and consent integral to monogamous and polyamorous relationships alike.

You often find that polyamory is an intentional choice built on openness and love, while bigamy may involve deceit and a lack of informed consent from all parties. The person who was deceived never had the chance to agree, which is exactly what separates it from ethical non-monogamy.

Impact on Families and Society

When considering families, polygamy and bigamy can present different dynamics. Polygamous families might have clear expectations and structures in place, such as sororal polygyny, where co-wives can be sisters, fostering a particular familial atmosphere. However, the impact on families where bigamy occurs can involve significant emotional distress due to the secretiveness and surprise when the deception comes to light.

From a societal perspective, the acceptance of these relationships can vary greatly by culture and religion. For instance, the Philippines criminalizes bigamy in general but allows Muslim men a second wife under strict conditions. In many societies, however, there are penalties or punishments for bigamy, considering it illegal.

Your understanding of these constructs should include an appreciation of the similarities and differences they share. Both polygamy and bigamy can challenge the traditional view of monogamous relationships but do so in fundamentally different ways, with distinctions in ethicality, consent, and societal acceptance playing pivotal roles.

Bigamy vs Polygamy at a Glance

BigamyPolygamy
What it meansMarrying again while a previous marriage is still legally validHaving more than one spouse at the same time
Type of termMainly a legal term for a crimeA description of a marriage system or family structure
Number of spousesUsually twoTwo or more
Do all spouses know?Often not; it frequently involves hiding the first marriage, though it can also happen by mistake, for example when someone wrongly believes a divorce was finalizedUsually yes, where it is an accepted custom
Legal statusA crime in every US state, the UK and CanadaRecognized in some countries, mostly in parts of Africa, the Middle East and Asia; not recognized in the US, UK or Canada
What happens to the later marriageGenerally not legally validValid only where the law allows it

Where polyamory fits

People sometimes lump polyamory in with both terms, but it is something different. Polyamory means having more than one loving relationship with the knowledge and consent of everyone involved, and it does not require marriage at all. Dating two people, or living as a throuple, is not bigamy as long as nobody holds two marriage licenses at once (here is what the law says about throuples). Our guide to polyamory vs polygamy explains the differences in more detail, and if your polycule chooses to stay closed, polyfidelity is the term you may hear. Some multi-partner families also hold a commitment ceremony with no legal force, which our guide to polyamorous weddings covers.

Because the law usually gives multi-partner families no framework, many people write their own agreements. Our ENM Relationship Agreement Template is a printable workbook for putting your agreements into words, covering time, home, money, sexual health and how you’ll review things. It is a living document for your relationship, not a legal contract, so for property, parenting or inheritance questions you’ll still want a lawyer.

bigamy vs polygamy

Notable Cases and Legal Precedents

Two court cases, more than a century apart, show how US law has treated plural marriage.

The landmark case of Reynolds v. United States (1879) held that laws prohibiting polygamy were constitutional, establishing that religious practices could not make polygamy exempt from law. George Reynolds, a member of the LDS Church in Utah Territory, had argued that his religion required plural marriage.

Its key line is still quoted today: laws “cannot interfere with mere religious belief and opinions, they may with practices” (National Constitution Center). In other words, believing in plural marriage is protected, but practicing it can be prohibited.

The most famous modern challenge came from Kody Brown and his wives, of the reality show “Sister Wives”. In Brown v. Buhman, a federal judge ruled in December 2013 that the part of Utah’s law banning cohabitation with more than one partner was unconstitutional, while leaving the ban on multiple marriage licenses in place. In April 2016 the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals threw the case out on standing grounds, because the local prosecutor had adopted a policy of not charging the family, so the earlier ruling was vacated. Utah later lowered its own penalties through S.B. 102 in 2020, as explained above.

The pattern across these cases is consistent: courts and lawmakers may soften how harshly bigamy is punished, but none of them has made a second simultaneous marriage legally valid in the US.

Implications for Family Law and Policy

When discussing bigamy and polygamy, it’s crucial to understand their legal status and implications within family law and policy. Bigamy, which involves someone marrying another person while still legally married to an existing spouse, is an offense across the United States.

Consequently, if you find yourself inadvertently in a bigamous relationship, the subsequent marriage is not legally recognized, which impacts your legal rights and responsibilities.

Bigamy in Law:

  • Criminal offense: Bigamy is a crime in every state, though penalties range from an infraction for consenting adults in Utah to felony charges elsewhere.
  • Annulment: Because the later marriage is generally not valid, the usual route out is an annulment, which can affect property, support and other rights the second spouse assumed they had.

Regarding polygamy, which refers to multiple simultaneous marriages, U.S. law does not recognize these unions; thus, they do not offer legal protection for spouses as standard marriages do.

Polygamy and Legal Implications:

  • Family Rights: Families formed through polygamous relationships may face challenges regarding parentage, inheritance, and benefits.

If you are in or considering a relationship that involves more than one marriage, only the first legal marriage will be recognized in the US. Any later partner has none of the legal protections of a spouse, which is why multi-partner families often ask a lawyer about wills and other documents, and write down their own agreements too.

bigamy vs polygamy

Frequently asked questions

Is bigamy the same as polygamy?

Not quite. Bigamy literally means being married twice, so it is technically a form of polygamy. In everyday and legal use, though, “bigamy” refers to the crime of entering a second marriage while the first is still valid, while “polygamy” describes having several spouses, whether or not the law allows it.

Is bigamy a felony?

It depends on where you are. In Illinois, for example, bigamy is a Class 4 felony. Colorado made it a misdemeanor in 2022, and Utah made bigamy between consenting adults an infraction in 2020, while keeping felony penalties where fraud, threats or abuse are involved. In the UK it is an offence under the Offences Against the Person Act 1861, and in Canada under section 290 of the Criminal Code. In every case, the later marriage is generally not legally valid.

In which countries is polygamy legally recognized?

Polygamy is legally recognized in a number of countries, mostly in parts of Africa, the Middle East and Asia, and each sets its own conditions. Recognition is not the same as common practice, though. According to Pew Research Center, only about 2% of the world’s population lives in polygamous households, rising to 11% in sub-Saharan Africa, with the highest shares in Burkina Faso (36%), Mali (34%) and Nigeria (28%).

Is it bigamy to date or live with more than one partner?

Generally no. Bigamy is about marriage, not dating. Having more than one partner with everyone’s consent, as in consensual non-monogamy, is not bigamy in most of the US as long as you hold only one marriage. There are exceptions worth knowing about: Colorado’s bigamy law also covers a married person who “cohabits in this state with another person”, and Canada’s polygamy offence covers “any kind of conjugal union with more than one person at the same time”. If you’re unsure, check your local rules or ask a lawyer.

What happens to a bigamous marriage?

In the US, UK and Canada, the later marriage is generally not legally valid, whatever ceremony took place. It is usually ended through an annulment, and the person who married twice may also face criminal charges unless a legal defense applies.

What is the difference between polygamy, polyandry and polyamory?

Polygamy means having more than one spouse at the same time. Polyandry is one form of it, where a woman has several husbands; it is much rarer than polygyny, where a man has several wives. Polyamory is having more than one loving relationship with the knowledge and consent of everyone involved, and it doesn’t require marriage at all. Not sure where you stand? Our free polyamory quiz is a gentle place to start reflecting.

In closing

The short version of bigamy vs polygamy: polygamy is the marriage pattern of having several spouses, and bigamy is what the law calls a second marriage it doesn’t allow. In the US, UK and Canada you can only be legally married to one person at a time, though many states give defenses for honest mistakes, and penalties range from an infraction to a felony. What makes the biggest difference to the people involved is usually consent: whether everyone knew and agreed. That is also the line between bigamy and the open, consensual relationships we write about here at ENM Living.

Sources

Newsletter

Enjoyed this article?

Get new articles in your inbox, plus reading paths and the occasional new tool. Unsubscribe in one click.