Silhouette of two people sitting together on a bench, a quiet moment for an honest talk about what each of them wants

I Want an Open Relationship but My Partner Doesn’t: What Now?

You’ve said it out loud, maybe after months of thinking about it, and the answer was no. Or perhaps you already know what your partner would say, so you haven’t asked yet. Either way, you’re sitting with a hard thought: I want an open relationship but my partner doesn’t. That can feel lonely, confusing and a little guilty all at once. This guide won’t tell you what to choose. It will help you understand the mismatch, look honestly at your options and take the next step with care, for you and for your partner.

First, you’re not alone, and you’re not “bad”

Interest in non-monogamy is more common than many people assume, including among people who are in monogamous relationships. In a study of 822 people in monogamous relationships, sex researcher Justin Lehmiller found that 32.6% said being in a sexually open relationship was part of their favourite sexual fantasy of all time. Of those, 80% said they’d like to act on it one day (Lehmiller, 2020, Archives of Sexual Behavior).

So the wish itself isn’t strange. But a fantasy, or even a strong desire, doesn’t decide anything on its own. Your relationship includes another person, with their own needs, fears and values. If you’d like to explore whether non-monogamy is part of who you are, or more of a curiosity, our guide on how to know if you’re polyamorous has questions to reflect on.

How strongly people feel this varies a lot. Relationship expert Effy Blue, who specialises in non-monogamy, notes in a piece for mindbodygreen that for some people their preference works like an orientation, while for others it’s a choice. She recounts a story from sociologist Elisabeth Sheff about a woman who said trying to be monogamous felt like “trying to wear a shoe that was three sizes too small” (mindbodygreen). Remember that the same depth of feeling can run the other way. Your partner’s “no” isn’t automatically fear or narrow-mindedness; they may simply be wired for, or committed to, something different.

Why a reluctant yes isn’t the goal

When you want something badly, it’s tempting to keep pushing until your partner gives in. Please don’t. Consent is what makes non-monogamy ethical, and consent given under pressure isn’t the real thing.

A reluctant yes often leads to an arrangement where one person is open and the other quietly suffers. Our guide to the one-sided open relationship looks at how hard that can be when it isn’t freely chosen. Pushing can also damage the trust you’d need for any version of openness to work later.

Signs you may be sliding into pressure:

  • You raise the topic again soon after a clear no, without anything having changed.
  • You frame their answer as a flaw (“you’re just insecure”) rather than a preference.
  • You hint that the relationship depends on it, without saying so clearly.
  • You send articles or videos to win the argument, rather than to understand each other.

Get specific about what you really want

“Open relationship” is a broad label. Before deciding anything, work out what you’re actually hoping for. SHIPS Psychology suggests clarifying your needs and how important each one is, and asking whether they could be met in other ways (SHIPS Psychology).

Try these journal prompts on your own first:

  1. “When I imagine being open, what exactly am I picturing? Who, what, how often?”
  2. “What feeling am I hoping for: novelty, freedom, being desired, deeper connection with others, community?”
  3. “Which of these needs is essential to me, and which would be nice to have?”
  4. “Is any of this about something missing in my current relationship? If so, what?”
  5. “What do I value so much in this relationship that I’d protect it even if I can’t have everything I want?”

Your answers may surprise you. Some people discover the core need is closer to “I want more adventure in my life” or “I miss feeling wanted,” which can open other paths. Others find their wish is steady, clear and central to who they are. Both are important to know. If you’re not sure which form of non-monogamy you’re drawn to, our overview of the types of open relationships can help you name it.

Understand your partner’s no

A no is a complete answer, and you don’t need to “solve” it. But if your partner is willing, understanding what sits behind it can help you both. SHIPS Psychology recommends staying curious about your partner’s view and moving from “me vs. my partner” to “us vs. the issue.” It also notes that “It is, therefore, normal for someone to react to the idea of change with insecurity, confusion, or uncertainty.”

Gentle questions you might ask, if and when your partner wants to talk:

  • “What did it feel like when I brought this up?”
  • “Is your answer about non-monogamy in general, or about something in our relationship right now?”
  • “Is there anything you’re worried I’m not telling you?”
  • “Would you like to never discuss this again, or is it okay to come back to it in a while?”

Respect the answer to that last question. If your partner wants the topic closed for now, keep it closed. Some of their reasons may be shaped by cultural expectations about love. Even so, you don’t get to decide those reasons are invalid. Unlearning is a personal choice, not something one partner does to another.

A hand holding a compass outdoors, like working out which direction feels right when you and your partner want different things

I want an open relationship but my partner doesn’t: your realistic options

There’s no single right path. SHIPS Psychology and Effy Blue’s mindbodygreen piece describe several of the options below. Which one fits depends on how central this wish is to you, how your partner feels and what the two of you can genuinely live with.

1. Choose monogamy, consciously

Some people decide the relationship matters more than this particular wish. That can be a healthy, wholehearted choice, as long as it’s a real choice and not quiet resignation. Ask yourself honestly whether you can let go of resentment. If you can’t, this option tends to leak out sideways.

2. Look for a middle ground

Blue suggests aiming for “synergy” rather than symmetry: partners don’t need to want exactly the same thing at the same time. A middle ground might mean finding new ways to bring adventure, novelty or freedom into your current relationship. SHIPS Psychology describes compromise as “when you and your partner(s) make mutual concessions for a shared goal,” and recommends regular check-ins to see whether it’s still working. It contrasts this with sacrifice, where only one person gives something up.

3. A mono-poly arrangement

In some relationships, one partner stays monogamous while the other is not. SHIPS Psychology notes this needs openness, honesty and communication. It can work when the monogamous partner truly wants it, not when they’re tolerating it. If you consider this, go slowly and agree that either of you can pause it.

4. Revisit later, without a deadline

Sometimes “no” means “not now.” Life stage, stress, health or simply needing time to think can all shape the answer. If your partner is open to it, you might agree to check in again in a few months. What matters is that it’s a shared plan, not a countdown you’re quietly running.

5. Part with care

If your needs are fundamentally different and neither of you can live with the alternatives, ending the relationship can be the most honest choice. Blue writes about “ending that relationship in a conscious and caring way.” SHIPS Psychology adds that “it is never a bad thing to be your true and authentic self.” This isn’t failure. It’s two people taking each other’s needs seriously.

What isn’t an option: going ahead in secret

It can be tempting to tell yourself “they’ll never know.” But non-monogamy without consent is cheating, whatever you call it. It takes away your partner’s right to make informed choices about their own relationship, and about their sexual health.

Scripts for the next conversation

If you do talk about it again, keep it calm and short, and lead with care. For help with the very first conversation, our guide on how to ask for an open relationship covers timing and openers. These lines are for after a no:

  • Acknowledging their answer: “I heard your no, and I’m not trying to change it. I just want us to understand each other.”
  • Sharing your side without pressure: “This isn’t going away for me, and I’d rather be honest about that than hide it.”
  • Exploring options: “Can we think together about whether there’s anything that would work for both of us, including staying as we are?”
  • Naming a hard truth: “I’m scared this might be a real difference between us. Could we talk to someone together to help us work it out?”

If these talks keep turning into arguments, our article on how to have difficult conversations with your partner has tools for slowing down and repairing.

Look after yourself through the uncertainty

Holding a want you can’t act on is hard. You might feel grief, frustration or shame, sometimes all in one day. Some ways to care for yourself:

  • Talk to someone outside the relationship. A trusted friend or a counsellor who understands non-monogamy can help you think clearly. SHIPS Psychology suggests both couples therapy and individual support.
  • Take your time. Blue describes “Taking your time” as key, and suggests you keep sharing enjoyable time together while you work through it.
  • Notice what you’re telling yourself. “I’m selfish” or “I’ll never be happy” are feelings, not facts.
  • Keep your relationship’s good parts alive. Don’t let one difference become the only topic between you.

It can also help to name, in writing, what you need emotionally. The Emotional Needs Assessment walks you through naming your needs, seeing where the gaps are and making a plan, which can bring real clarity to a conversation like this.

A note: ENM Living shares general information, not professional advice. If this mismatch is causing ongoing distress, conflict or anxiety, please consider speaking with a qualified counsellor or therapist, ideally one experienced with non-monogamy. If you ever feel unsafe or controlled in your relationship, seek support from a professional or a local support service.

Frequently asked questions

Is it wrong to want an open relationship when my partner doesn’t?

No. Wanting something different from your partner isn’t wrong. What matters is what you do with it: being honest, respecting their answer and not pressuring them.

Should I keep asking until my partner says yes?

No. Repeatedly raising it after a clear no can become pressure, and a yes given under pressure isn’t real consent. If your partner is willing, agree together on whether and when to talk again.

Can a monogamous person and a non-monogamous person stay together?

Some do, through a conscious choice of monogamy, a negotiated middle ground or a mono-poly arrangement. Others find the difference is too big. It depends on how central the need is for each of you and whether any option feels genuinely good to both.

Will my partner change their mind?

Nobody can predict that. Sometimes a no softens over time; sometimes it stays firm. It’s safest to make decisions based on your partner’s answer now, not on the one you hope for.

Is it cheating if I’m only flirting or chatting with someone else?

That depends on what you and your partner have agreed. If you’re doing something you’d hide from them, or that breaks your shared agreements, it’s worth treating that as a sign to talk honestly.

Do we need a therapist?

Not necessarily, but it can help if conversations keep stalling or turning into conflict. Look for someone who is welcoming of all relationship styles, so neither of you feels judged.

In closing

Realising “I want an open relationship but my partner doesn’t” isn’t the end of the story. It’s the start of a more honest one. Get clear on what you need, respect your partner’s answer, look at every option with open eyes and take your time. Whatever you choose together, choosing it honestly is what protects you both.

Sources

Newsletter

Enjoyed this article?

Get new articles in your inbox, plus reading paths and the occasional new tool. Unsubscribe in one click.