Search for open relationships online and you’ll quickly find a wave of warnings. Maybe you’ve wondered yourself why open relationships don’t work, or whether yours is heading that way. The honest answer is that some do and some don’t, just like monogamous relationships. Research doesn’t show that opening up is doomed, but it does point to a handful of common traps. This guide walks through seven of them, and what you can do to give your relationship a fair chance.
Do open relationships fail more often than monogamous ones?
It’s a fair question, and the evidence is more reassuring than the headlines. A widely cited research review, “Consensual Nonmonogamy: Psychological Well-Being and Relationship Quality Correlates”, concluded that consensual non-monogamists show “similar psychological well-being and relationship quality as monogamists” (abstract).
A later study by Annelise Parkes Murphy, Samantha Joel and Amy Muise followed 233 people who were considering opening their relationships. Over about two months, 155 of them did. Those who opened up tended to report increases in sexual satisfaction, while their relationship quality and life satisfaction didn’t meaningfully change either way. The researchers said: “The biggest takeaway from the current data is that we found no support for either of these ideas,” meaning that opening up neither harmed nor fixed relationships on average (PsyPost, 2020).
Kinsey Institute research fellow Justin Lehmiller notes in his write-up that people who opened up were already more satisfied with their relationships at the start, which suggests happier couples were the ones more likely to try it. He also points out the study only lasted two months (Psychology Today, 2026). So the research has limits, but it doesn’t support the idea that open relationships are bound to fail. For a deeper look at the evidence, read are open relationships healthy?
Why open relationships don’t work: 7 common reasons
When an open relationship does struggle, it’s usually for reasons that have little to do with non-monogamy itself. Here are the patterns that come up again and again.
1. Opening up to fix a relationship that’s already struggling
It’s tempting to hope that new partners will ease boredom, resentment or mismatched desire. Kinsey Institute executive director Dr. Justin Garcia, quoted by VICE, warns that open relationships bring “the same issues that plague monogamous relationships, mismatched libidos, jealousy, boredom, and more” (VICE, 2026). Opening up tends to put pressure on whatever’s already shaky.
What helps: Work on the core relationship first. If you’re not sure whether you’re opening up for the right reasons, talk to a non-monogamy-aware counsellor before you start.
2. One partner is going along with it
Licensed counsellor Tracy Smith, LPC, notes that “Usually, one partner suggests the idea of an open relationship to the other,” and that the less enthusiastic partner may simply be going along with it (E-Counseling). A reluctant yes often turns into resentment.
What helps: Make it genuinely safe to say no, or “not yet.” Try saying: “I’d rather hear a real no than a yes you don’t mean. I want to know what you actually want.”
3. Monogamy is genuinely the better fit
Elisabeth Sheff, PhD, a researcher of polyamorous and sexual-minority families, writes that “Some people are deeply, innately, wired for monogamy.” She also says some people simply don’t like to share, which she describes as a valid personal boundary rather than a flaw (Psychology Today, 2020).
What helps: Treat a preference for monogamy with the same respect as a preference for openness. If you and your partner want genuinely different things, it’s a compatibility question, not a character flaw.
4. Jealousy and comparison without tools to handle them
Smith describes jealousy as “a normal human emotion and one that can cause significant strife for a couple,” and adds that comparing yourself with a partner’s other partners can hit self-esteem hard. Jealousy itself isn’t a sign that you’re doing it wrong. Not having a plan for it is the bigger problem.
What helps: Agree in advance how you’ll handle a jealous moment, from asking for reassurance to taking a pause. Our guide to jealousy in an open relationship has practical steps.
5. Uneven power and lopsided outcomes
Smith also points out that open relationships can involve an “inequitable balance of power,” for example when one partner finds dates easily and the other doesn’t, or when one outside connection becomes more significant than expected. Left unspoken, that imbalance breeds anger and resentment.
What helps: Talk about how you’ll handle uneven experiences before they happen. Choosing a style that fits you both, from occasional swinging to fully independent dating, also helps. See our overview of the types of open relationships.
6. Underestimating the work, and leaving agreements vague
Garcia notes that “Even casual polyamorous encounters take substantial effort and negotiation” (VICE). Scheduling, check-ins and conversations about safer sex all take time and energy. When agreements are vague (“just be careful”), each person fills in the gaps differently.
What helps: Write down what you’ve agreed, keep it short and specific, and set a date to review it.
7. Honesty starts to slip
“When honesty disappears, trust usually follows right behind it,” writes Smith. Small omissions, such as not mentioning a date or downplaying feelings, can quietly erode trust across the whole relationship.
What helps: Agree on what you’ll share and when, and stick to it. If something feels hard to say, that’s usually a sign it needs saying. Our guide on how to have difficult conversations with your partner can help.

How to give your open relationship a fair chance
None of these traps is inevitable. A few habits can make your relationship much more resilient.
- Get clear on your reasons. Each of you writes down why you want to open up and what you hope will change. Compare notes before you go further.
- Pick a starting point, not a final form. Many couples begin with something limited and expand later if it’s going well.
- Agree on the essentials. Cover disclosure, safer sex, time and money, and what happens if feelings develop.
- Schedule check-ins. A short weekly conversation catches problems while they’re small.
- Keep a pause button. Agree that either of you can ask to slow down or pause, and that this will be taken seriously.
- Look after the people you date. Other partners are people, not add-ons. Being honest and considerate with them protects everyone.
A check-in prompt you can use: “What’s felt good this week? What’s felt hard? Is there anything you need from me before next week?”
If you’re still deciding which structure suits you, our explainer on polyamorous vs open relationships lays out the differences.
When closing the relationship is the right call
Sometimes an open relationship ends, or a couple decides to return to monogamy. That isn’t necessarily a failure. You may have learned something important about what you each need. Closing can be the right choice when one of you consistently feels unsafe or unhappy, when agreements keep being broken, or when the arrangement is taking more than it gives. Make the decision together, with kindness, and give yourselves time to adjust.
A starting point for couples
If you’re thinking about opening up, or want to restart on firmer ground, Opening Up: A Starter Guide for Couples helps you talk about why you want this, choose a style that fits and look after each other along the way.
A note: ENM Living shares general information, not professional, medical or legal advice. If your relationship is in crisis, or you’re feeling pressured into an arrangement you don’t want, please reach out to a qualified, non-monogamy-aware counsellor or therapist. For questions about sexual health, speak to a sexual-health clinic or doctor.
Frequently asked questions
Why do open relationships fail?
When they struggle, common reasons include opening up to fix existing problems, one partner reluctantly agreeing, unmanaged jealousy, power imbalances, vague agreements and slipping honesty. Many of these also affect monogamous relationships.
Are open relationships less happy than monogamous ones?
A widely cited research review found broadly similar well-being and relationship quality among people in consensual non-monogamy and monogamy. Individual experiences vary widely.
Can opening up save a struggling relationship?
It’s unlikely on its own. A study of people opening their relationships found no evidence that it fixed relationship quality, although sexual satisfaction tended to rise. Existing problems usually need attention first.
What if my partner wants an open relationship and I don’t?
Your no is valid. Talk honestly about what each of you wants and why. If your needs are truly incompatible, a counsellor can help you work out what comes next.
Is it normal to feel jealous in an open relationship?
Yes. Jealousy is a normal emotion. It doesn’t mean the relationship is failing, but it helps to have a shared plan for handling it.
Can you go back to monogamy after an open relationship?
Yes. Some couples close their relationship after trying openness. It works best as a shared, considered decision rather than a reaction in the middle of a conflict.
In closing
Open relationships don’t fail because they’re open. They struggle for very human reasons: unspoken doubts, unclear agreements and hard feelings without a plan. Go slowly, stay honest, and keep checking in. Whether you end up open, closed or somewhere in between, the goal is a relationship that works for everyone in it.
Sources
- Consensual nonmonogamy: psychological well-being and relationship quality correlates. Taylor & Francis; abstract via QxMD.
- Dolan, E. W. (2020). What changes when couples open their relationship? Surprisingly little, new research suggests. PsyPost.
- Fike, A. (2026). The 3 most common reasons open relationships fail. VICE.
- Lehmiller, J. J. (2026). What happens when a couple opens their relationship? Psychology Today.
- Sheff, E. A. (2020). When consensual non-monogamy won’t work for monogamous folks. Psychology Today.
- Smith, T. (2025). Why open relationships don’t work: 7 reasons. E-Counseling.
Enjoyed this article?
Get new articles in your inbox, plus reading paths and the occasional new tool. Unsubscribe in one click.
You’ll receive a confirmation email first. Privacy policy



