An hourglass on a dark table, a symbol of time and whether an open relationship lasts

Open Relationship Success Rate: What the Research Really Shows

If you’re thinking about opening your relationship, it’s natural to want odds. What’s the open relationship success rate? Do most couples who try it stay together, or does it usually end in heartbreak? You’ll find confident numbers online, often with no source attached. This guide looks at what research can actually tell you, what it can’t, and which factors seem to separate open relationships that thrive from those that struggle, so you can judge your own chances more clearly.

Is there an open relationship success rate?

Short answer: not one you can trust. When we looked for an open relationship success rate, we didn’t find a study that follows a representative group of open relationships over many years and reports how many last. The studies below are useful, but they are snapshots or volunteer surveys, not long-term tracking.

There are good reasons a single number is hard to produce:

  • “Open” covers many arrangements. Swinging, casual outside sex, polyamory and one-sided setups all get lumped together, but they work very differently. Our guide to the types of open relationships explains the main styles.
  • “Success” means different things. Is it staying together? Staying happy? Staying open? A couple who closes their relationship again and stays together might call that a success or a failure.
  • Volunteer samples skew things. People who answer surveys about non-monogamy may be more positive about it than the average person who tries it.

So instead of one number, it’s more useful to ask: what kinds of open relationships tend to go well, and why?

What one large study found: the “three Cs”

Researchers in Ronald Rogge’s lab at the University of Rochester analysed online questionnaires from 1,658 people, most in long-term relationships averaging nearly four and a half years. Published in the Journal of Sex Research, the study sorted people into five groups: two monogamous groups, a consensually non-monogamous group, a partially open group and a one-sided group (University of Rochester, 2019).

The team looked at what they call the “Triple-C” model: whether partners mutually consent to, communicate about and feel comfortable with their relationship arrangements. Here’s what they found:

  • Consensual non-monogamy did well. The consensually non-monogamous group showed high relationship and individual functioning, with loneliness and distress as low as the monogamous groups.
  • Partially open and one-sided groups struggled. They showed lower functioning, with higher distress, loneliness and attachment avoidance. They also tended to be in newer relationships and reported lower dedication and affection.
  • One-sided arrangements fared worst. 60% of people in the one-sided group were significantly dissatisfied with their relationships, nearly three times the rate of the monogamous or consensually non-monogamous groups (Futurity, 2019).

Rogge put it plainly: secrecy surrounding sexual activity with others “can all too easily become toxic.” He described communication as “critical for couples in nonmonogamous relationships.”

One important limit: the data captured a single moment in time, so the researchers couldn’t say whether these factors cause better or worse outcomes. Still, the pattern is a useful guide. The relationships that looked healthiest weren’t defined by being open or closed. They were defined by everyone genuinely agreeing, talking and feeling okay with the arrangement.

If you and your partner don’t agree on opening up in the first place, our guide I want an open relationship but my partner doesn’t looks at your options without pressure.

Two hands gently holding each other, showing the care and consent that help open relationships last

Do open and polyamorous relationships last?

Duration is the closest thing most people mean by “success,” and here the evidence is limited but encouraging. Writing in Psychology Today, journalist Michael Castleman describes a 2011 study by Kauppi and Whitter, “Longevity and Intimacy in Polyamorous Relationships” (Psychology Today, 2021). According to his summary:

  • The researchers surveyed 340 coupled adults in consensually open relationships, recruited through polyamory websites.
  • On average, respondents had been polyamorous for eight years.
  • Primary relationships averaged eight years and secondary relationships averaged five.
  • 20% had been together for a decade or longer.
  • All relationship types showed high emotional and sexual intimacy, though primary relationships were more intimate than secondary ones.

Castleman’s conclusion is that “many polyam relationships last quite a while.” He also offers an important caveat: because respondents were recruited through polyamory websites, they may have been more successful than most, so the findings can’t be extended to all polyamorous relationships.

Polyamory and open relationships aren’t identical, and our explainer on polyamorous vs open relationships covers the differences. But the study is a useful counterweight to the idea that non-monogamous relationships are always short-lived.

For a wider look at what research says about satisfaction and well-being, read are open relationships healthy?

Rethinking what “success” means

Asking “will it last?” is understandable, but it can hide other questions worth asking. A relationship can be long and unhappy, or shorter and genuinely good for everyone in it. Consider defining success in ways you can actually check:

  • Everyone involved is choosing this freely, not tolerating it.
  • Agreements are kept, and changed openly when they stop working.
  • Hard feelings can be spoken without fear of punishment or mockery.
  • Your core relationship still feels cared for, not neglected.
  • If you close the relationship or part ways, you do it honestly and kindly.

By that measure, a couple who opens up, learns it isn’t for them, and closes again with care hasn’t failed. They’ve found out something true about themselves. Our article on why open relationships don’t work for some couples looks at the common traps, and when closing can be the right call.

How to improve your own odds

You can’t control every outcome, but the “three Cs” give you a practical checklist. Here’s how to put each one into practice.

Consent: make sure it’s mutual and ongoing

  • Check that each of you would choose this even if the other weren’t asking.
  • Agree that either of you can ask to pause or slow down, and that the request will be honoured.
  • Revisit consent when circumstances change, such as a new partner, a move or a new baby.

Try saying: “I want this to be something we both choose, not something you’re putting up with. Is that still true for you?”

Communication: talk before, during and after

  • Agree what you’ll share about other connections, and when.
  • Set a regular check-in, even a short one, so small worries come up early.
  • Talk about the practical side too: time, money, safer sex and privacy.

Check-in prompts: “What felt good about our arrangement this month? What felt hard? Is there anything I don’t know that I should?”

Comfort: notice how it actually feels

  • Pay attention to persistent dread, resentment or numbness. They’re signs to slow down, not flaws to hide.
  • Adjust the pace to the more hesitant partner.
  • Be willing to change the arrangement, or close it, if one of you consistently isn’t okay.

Try saying: “On a scale of one to ten, how comfortable are you with how things are right now? What would make it one point better?”

Put it in writing

Many couples find it easier to stay on the same page when their agreements are written down and reviewed. The ENM Relationship Agreement Template helps you write clear, kind agreements together and keep them up to date as your relationship changes.

A note: ENM Living shares general information, not professional, medical or mental-health advice. If your relationship is causing ongoing distress, or if anyone feels pressured or unsafe, please speak with a qualified counsellor or therapist, ideally one experienced with non-monogamy. For sexual-health questions, talk to a doctor or sexual-health clinic.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of open relationships work?

We couldn’t find a reliable, research-based percentage. Studies of open relationships mostly use volunteer samples and single snapshots in time, so any precise “success rate” you see quoted online should be treated with caution unless it links to a real study.

Do open relationships end more often than monogamous ones?

The studies we reviewed don’t show that. The Rochester study found consensually non-monogamous people doing about as well as monogamous people on several measures, while one-sided and partially open arrangements struggled more.

How long do polyamorous relationships last?

In one survey of 340 polyamorous adults, primary relationships averaged eight years and 20% had lasted a decade or more. The sample came from polyamory websites, so it may not represent everyone.

What makes an open relationship successful?

Research points to mutual consent, good communication and genuine comfort with your agreements. Practical habits such as regular check-ins, written agreements and a shared pause button help put those into practice.

Is a one-sided open relationship likely to work?

It can, but the evidence suggests it’s harder. In the Rochester study, 60% of people in one-sided arrangements were significantly dissatisfied. If you’re in one, it’s worth checking honestly whether both of you are choosing it freely.

In closing

There’s no trustworthy open relationship success rate to lean on, and that’s not a bad thing. Your relationship isn’t a statistic. What the research does suggest is encouraging: when everyone consents, keeps talking and genuinely feels okay with the arrangement, open relationships can do as well as monogamous ones. Focus on those three things, and you give yourselves the best chance, whatever shape your relationship ends up taking.

Sources

Newsletter

Enjoyed this article?

Get new articles in your inbox, plus reading paths and the occasional new tool. Unsubscribe in one click.